Save 20-35% on Marvel Pre-Orders at
Search Comichron for comics sales reports!

More on "The Rule of Eight"

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

by John Jackson Miller

Following yesterday's mention of his Rule of Eight — an observation relating to the survival rates for independent publishers whose lines expanded quickly — Marc Patten wrote to remind me of an important nuance: "If memory serves, I think the 'Rule of 8' stemmed from the concept of new companies with some sort of shared universe concept, rather than just number of titles."

Thus, the eight-monthly-title barrier he perceived would not necessarily apply to publishers with differentiated lines. Dark Horse and Image both had mini-universes (Dark Horse with "Comics Greatest World" and Image with its families of studio titles), but in either case no one shared-universe sub-line accounted for more than half the publisher's output.

But when it comes to firms where the majority of the publisher's business relied on a shared universe, eight monthly titles appears to have been more of a red line, historically: Valiant/Acclaim, Tekno•Comix, and CrossGen are among the companies that vanished after crossing it. "There is still no shared-universe line that has managed to survive outside of Marvel/DC to date as far as I know," Patten says, beyond that eight-monthly limit.

There are likely exceptions to be argued with the formulation, but the larger point is this: the expansion seen in middle-tier companies today is in some ways different from the expansion seen in the 1990s. Publisher lines are more differentiated internally, and less reliant upon individual customers who buy everything. Comics have become, like many other media, more grazer-friendly.


Anonymous,  March 16, 2012 at 8:46 AM  

Hey I'm curious, I noticed a pattern that after issue 1 on any comic, the sales go down and rarely go back up to what the first issue sold. With the DC's NEW 52, is there an increase in readership, or is it the same old fan base collecting the new material? See I wanna know if American comics are expanding like the Japanese are, or if it's shrinking with the very hardcore still reading.

John Jackson Miller March 16, 2012 at 9:28 AM  

I haven't really looked at any one publisher's titles too closely, but declines after the first issue is the natural pattern for American comics, probably occurring more than 90% of the time. This has been the case for decades. First issues often had an additional after-market value, and many people sample the first issue and then wait for the trade.

But the bigger reason is that since retailers order comics in advance, when they order second and third issues they usually don't have full information about how #1 sold, so they are more conservative. There are occasions where it goes up -- like Civil War or Jim Lee's Batman run -- but it usually requires there being a lot of extra copies printed of the second and third issues to meet the reorder demand.

Post a Comment

Recent Comments

Faraway Looks: The Blog of John Jackson Miller

  © Blogger template The Professional Template II by 2009

Back to TOP